Current:Home > ScamsNew Mexico Supreme Court rules tribal courts have jurisdiction over casino injury and damage cases-LoTradeCoin
New Mexico Supreme Court rules tribal courts have jurisdiction over casino injury and damage cases
View Date:2024-12-23 23:00:26
ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (AP) — The New Mexico Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled that tribal courts have jurisdiction over personal injury and property damage cases brought against Native American casinos, ending a long battle that saw pueblos and other tribes advocate for protecting sovereignty when such legal claims arise.
The decision stemmed from a 2016 lawsuit in which an employee of an electrical company claimed he was severely injured while making a delivery at Pojoaque Pueblo’s casino. The state Court of Appeals had reversed a lower court ruling that initially called for the case to be dismissed.
The tribe then asked the state Supreme Court to settle the question over jurisdiction.
In its ruling, the court pointed to previous decisions in two federal cases that effectively terminated a provision in tribal-state gambling compacts that waived sovereign immunity to allow jurisdiction to be moved from tribal court to state court for some damage claims.
One of those federal cases involved a personal injury claim involving the over-serving of alcohol at Santa Ana Pueblo’s casino. The other was a slip-and-fall lawsuit brought in state court by a visitor to the Navajo Nation’s casino in northwestern New Mexico.
Attorney Richard Hughes had filed a brief on behalf of Santa Ana and Santa Clara pueblos, with seven other pueblos signing on. He told The Associated Press on Tuesday that the ruling was significant and long overdue.
“We’ve been fighting state court jurisdiction over these cases for 20 years and so it’s the end of a long struggle to keep state courts out of determining tribal affairs,” he said.
He and others have argued that nowhere in the federal Indian Gaming Regulatory Act did Congress authorize state courts to exercise jurisdiction over personal injury claims.
The New Mexico Trial Lawyers Association did not immediately return a message seeking comment on the ruling.
Those who have advocated to have state courts hear personal injury cases contend that the people suing tribal gambling operations could face an unfair disadvantage in tribal court.
Some experts expect personal injury lawyers to opt for arbitration before heading to tribal court, but Hughes said tribal courts are “perfectly competent to handle cases like this in a very fair and equitable fashion.”
veryGood! (7)
Related
- New York eyes reviving congestion pricing toll before Trump takes office
- 1 dead, at least 22 wounded in mass shooting at Juneteenth celebration in Illinois
- This Week in Clean Economy: West Coast ‘Green’ Jobs Data Shows Promise
- Man arrested after allegedly throwing phone at Bebe Rexha during concert
- Denver district attorney is investigating the leak of voting passwords in Colorado
- Alaska’s Hottest Month on Record: Melting Sea Ice, Wildfires and Unexpected Die-Offs
- Foo Fighters Reveal Their New Drummer One Year After Taylor Hawkins' Death
- Transcript: Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie on Face the Nation, June 18, 2023
- Best fits for Corbin Burnes: 6 teams that could match up with Cy Young winner
- Q&A: Black scientist Antentor Hinton Jr. talks role of Juneteenth in STEM, need for diversity in field
Ranking
- As the transition unfolds, Trump eyes one of his favorite targets: US intelligence
- This Week in Clean Economy: West Coast ‘Green’ Jobs Data Shows Promise
- In a supreme court race like no other, Wisconsin's political future is up for grabs
- Anne Hathaway's Stylist Erin Walsh Explains the Star's Groundbreaking Fashion Era
- Early Black Friday Deals: 70% Off Apple, Dyson, Tarte, Barefoot Dreams, Le Creuset & More + Free Shipping
- 'Cancel culture is a thing.' Jason Aldean addresses 'Small Town' backlash at Friday night show
- Siberian Wildfires Prompt Russia to Declare a State of Emergency
- Joy-Anna Duggar Gives Birth, Welcomes New Baby With Austin Forsyth
Recommendation
-
Fire crews gain greater control over destructive Southern California wildfire
-
Transcript: Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie on Face the Nation, June 18, 2023
-
Padel, racket sport played in at least 90 countries, is gaining attention in U.S.
-
Man arrested after allegedly throwing phone at Bebe Rexha during concert
-
To Protect the Ozone Layer and Slow Global Warming, Fertilizers Must Be Deployed More Efficiently, UN Says
-
Robert De Niro and Girlfriend Tiffany Chen Step Out at Cannes Film Festival After Welcoming Baby
-
Jessica Alba Shares Sweet Selfie With Husband Cash Warren on Their 15th Anniversary
-
In a supreme court race like no other, Wisconsin's political future is up for grabs